What to Eat in Iceland?

The Best Food in Iceland

So, you’re in Iceland, and you’re trying to figure out what to eat. Until relatively recently, food in Iceland meant fish and lamb and maybe some potatoes with canned or frozen vegetables on the side. That’s why we may not have had a reputation of the most famous international food, but since then, our habits have changed a lot, and now everyone who gets the taste of our cuisine wants more. Over time, a lot of unique, modern recipes were created, and now we have some quite tasty dishes and goodies we eat day-to-day. Here’s what to eat when you’re in Iceland:

Fresh Seafood Dishes

We take our fish and seafood seriously, and it has a long tradition here. Fishing is not only an important part of our history but also a national dish. Now, do we eat fish every day? Not quite. More like twice a week. But since you’re here, you should really try as many of our regular seafood dishes as possible! Think about it – just earlier that day, the fish that you’re eating was caught, due to our natural resources! Can’t get fresher than that.

A pro tip: If you want to make sure that you’re eating fish that has been caught the same day, look for the “fish of the day” option on the menu or ask the waiter about it.

White Ocean Fish

Icelandic restaurants offer a great variety of saltwater white fish, and we can assure you that it is nowhere near as well prepared as here! Cod, haddock, wolffish, or fatty flesh of the unusual male monkfish – it’s up to you. Generally, white ocean fish has a milder flavour than other kinds.

Pink River Fish

In Icelandic rivers and lakes, one can find pink river fish, .e.g, rainbow trout, salmon, and Arctic char, which is rare in other places of the world (and it’s also the most delicious, in our opinion). Now, not every rainbow trout will have pink flesh; it can be white, as well, but the former is somewhat tastier. While river fish has that distinctive rich taste, you’ll find that the Arctic char has a flavour profile similar to trout, and is generally bigger than salmon. In any case, all of them will be prepared with delicious and edible crispy skin!

Plokkfiskur (Fish Stew)

When one says “stew,” you usually imagine veggies floating in the water, but this one is different. It’s more like fish chowder. It consists of white fish, potatoes, flour, milk, and onions, but really, every family has its own recipe for making it. It’s one of those foods that we’ve grown up with, and that reminds us of our granny and childhood days! In the restaurants, you’ll usually find the variety described above, though some variations also contain fresh chives, cheese, curry, etc.

Humar (Icelandic Lobster) 

You’ll never have a more delicious fresh lobster than Icelandic Humar (also known as Langoustine). Grilled, fried, cooked? It can be found in any shape, even as a pizza topping! While at it, you can also try Creamy Langoustine Soup (Humarsúpa). We often eat it during winter and holiday time.

Harðfiskur (Fish jerky)

This is a traditional Icelandic snack that you can get at a grocery store or the market, and it is basically dried fish strips. While pretty salty, it is also healthy. It has a surprisingly low amount of fat, and it is high in protein (82%!). But really – this is something you must try. It is consumed either straight out of the bag (like any snack), or with butter spread over it so that it drowns out the salty taste a bit. If you are interested in learning more about traditional Icelandic meals, see here our blog about Traditional Foods in Iceland You Should Try.

 

 

Meat for True Gourmets

Icelandic food is not only famous for fish but also meat, especially lamb. Our restaurants for fine dining offer a wide variety of par excellence meat dishes.

Hangikjöt

This smoked lamb is most commonly eaten in thin slices that are put into sandwiches or flatkaka (flat bread). One thing’s for sure – its appetizing aroma will have your mouth watering.

Kjötsúpa (Meat Soup)

The soup is made with chops of lamb, cooked vegetables (cabbage, carrots, potatoes, onion, garlic, and cauliflower). Its taste is enhanced with herbs (for instance, thyme & oregano) so that the flavour is subtle with a hint of pungent note.

Pylsa (Traditional Hot Dog)

In case you want a quick meal anywhere in town, try our hot dog that is made of a quality meat bland – lamb, beef, and pork. You can also get it with some add-ons, such as onions and sauces. Quick and yummy! They can be found on street vendors and fast food places all around Iceland.

Confectionery

If you want to make your Icelandic days sweeter and satiate your sweet tooth, here’s a list of irresistible things you should try:

Licorice

Licorice is unavoidable. It’s the first thing you will notice in the candy aisle. Most popular are chocolate bars with licorice, but there are also licorice-powdered nuts, dried fruits, etc. Believe it or not, there’s even licorice ice cream (eating black ice cream is quite an interesting experience), and there’s an option to dip it in licorice powder, but it’s a bit too much even for natives. Objectively, licorice has a distinctive flavor, and many people agree that it’s an acquired taste, but you should definitely give it a shot.

Opal Candy

Opal candy is one of the staples of Icelandic candy with its iconic Hypno spiral packaging. These are pastilles based on – yeah, you guessed it – licorice and menthol.

Icelandic Ice Cream

No matter how cold it is, we always enjoy ice cream. There are many ice cream parlors spread across our cities, and we suggest you don’t miss out on some soft ice cream with a variety of toppings. Our favorite combination? We are going to let you take a guess on that 😉

Skyr

If you have seen our blog “Traditional foods in Iceland”, you might have seen that Sky is mentioned there. We just love it so much that we are including it here to!

Skyr is sometimes classified as yoghurt. Actually, it has a texture that is more dense, like that of Greek yoghurt, and it tastes wonderful. You can find many varieties – plain, blueberry, vanilla, strawberry, etc. – and they are all high-protein.

Final Words

When the question of what to eat in Iceland pops out, these things mentioned above are the answer, as they are specialties that shouldn’t be omitted. And when you cross them out of the food bucket list, you should move on to fermented shark and similar traditional delicacies.

Verði þér að góðu! (aka enjoy your meal)!


Have you seen our blogs about

Traditional Foods in Iceland You Should Try

Fine Dining in Reykjavik

Best Fast Food & Street Food in Reykjavik

Best Asian Restaurants in Reykjavik


 

Leave a Reply

Newsletter

Need more information?

Simply give us a call. We have a team of travel specialists that are here to help you.

+354 520 5200

gjtravel@gjtravel.is

Proceed Booking

Secret Link